Arquivos Eletrobras privatization

Aroldo Cedraz — Foto: Fabio Rodrigues Pozzebom/Agência Brasil

After almost five hours of speeches, the Federal Court of Accounts (TCU) passed in a floor vote Wednesday the government project for the privatization of state-run power utility Eletrobras. The majority of the TCU members followed the opinion of the rapporteur, Aroldo Cedraz, defeating TCU member Vital do Rêgo, who suggested several adjustments in the process. TCU is a public spending watchdog not related with Brazil’s Judiciary system.

The decision ends a process started in 2018, still in the Temer administration. If completed, it will be the first privatization of the Bolsonaro administration.

With the green light from the auditing agency, the government wants to file next week the operation to increase the company’s capital at the Securities and Exchange Commission of Brazil (CVM) and the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).

In parallel, the syndicate of banks responsible for the operation — led by BTG — will make a road show with local and foreign investors. Some financial centers, such as New York and London, will certainly be on the institution’s route.

The government will also launch, through Caixa Econômica Federal, a platform in the Workers’ Severance Fund (FGTS) application through which workers can opt to invest part of their funds to buy Eletrobras shares. The government plans to use up to R$6 billion from the fund.

Next, there will be the so-called book building: the collection of investors’ indication of interest in acquiring the stocks. The demand will determine the final price of the shares, when the settlement will finally take place. It is expected to take place by the end of June.

After the operation, the federal government’s stake in Eletrobras’s voting capital will be reduced to 45% from 72%. The control will then be held by individual shareholders, in a model known as corporation, in which there is no major shareholder.

TCU’s approval was announced after the presentation of a reviewing vote by Mr. do Rêgo. He pointed out at least six alleged illegalities in the privatization process, among them a possible involuntary privatization of Eletronuclear, a subsidiary that should remain under control of the federal government.

This would happen because Eletronuclear owes R$2.7 billion to Eletrobras, referring to dividends withheld since 2010. In addition to pointing out the absence of this debt in Eletrobras financial statements, Mr. do Rêgo said that the form of payment could transfer to individual shareholders the largest share of Eletronuclear.

Under the design presented by the government, at the end of the privatization, the federal government would have 64% of the voting capital of Eletronuclear, with the new Eletrobras holding the remaining 36%. The private-sector partners would also hold 99% of Eletronuclear’s preferred shares, without voting rights.

However, the debt between the two companies could change this correlation. According to current legislation, preferred shares become entitled to voting rights if dividends have not been duly paid.

In this scenario, considering the R$2.7 billion debt, the private-sector partners would have a majority in Eletronuclear’s voting capital, which in practice mean that it would be privatized. “Brazilian nuclear policy is going to be privatized. Not even the most democratic country in the world has abdicated its nuclear policy,” Mr. do Rêgo said.

He also presented problems in the Eletrobras contingency policy. The company set aside R$9 billion for potential legal expenses only in last year’s third-quarter earnings report, which raised the total amount of provisions to R$26 billion.

According to Mr. do Rêgo, depending on the outcome of the lawsuits that motivated the contingencies, the federal government could be harmed. This is because an eventual victory of the state-run company in the courts would transform the provisions into profit and, consequently, in dividends for individual shareholders, who will have a larger share.

He also pointed out flaws in hydroelectric dam Itaipu’s pricing and classified the privatization as “outrageous” and “a sweetheart deal.” “Itaipu is being almost given away. There is a plot behind all of this,” Mr. do Rêgo said.

The arguments were not enough to change the course of the trial and the privatization was authorized by seven votes in favor and only one against. The head of TCU, Ana Arraes, was the only one to show support for Mr. do Rêgo’s thesis. Even so, she did not vote, since this only happens when a tie-breaker is needed.

The other members defended the legality of the process and recalled that the market would correct any distortion presented by Mr. do Rêgo’s vote.

“Within the defeat of the thesis, we had a clear victory. The illegalities pointed out by me remain, in my opinion, unclear. During the debates, it was said that the market could adjust the directions of privatization. But it is not the constitutional duty of the market to correct the illegalities identified,” said the defeated TCU member. He believes that the case will eventually go to the courts.

Source: Valor International

https://valorinternational.globo.com

Acionistas aprovam privatização da Eletrobras em assembleia - 22/02/2022 - Mercado - Folha

Eletrobras’s shareholders approved Tuesday, in an online extraordinary general meeting, the terms of the privatization of Brazil’s main power utility, sources say. With the approval, the company overcomes one more step in the obstacle course to make possible its capitalization process within the expected term, in the second quarter.

Valor found out that there were questions from minority shareholders, in the figure of the former board member of the state-owned company, João Antônio Lian, and from the Association of Employees of Eletrobras (AEEL), through a legal representative.

The digital voting was interrupted a few times, so that the company’s management could prepare explanations for each questioning. In the end, the items were all voted on with a wide margin of acceptance by the minority shareholders. The federal government abstained.

After more than five hours of voting, the shareholders greenlighted the privatization of Eletrobras. The item, the last one on the meeting’s long agenda, was approved by holders of 202 million of the company’s common shares, while shareholders representing 9,749 shares were opposed. The abstentions in this discussion totaled 884 million votes.

The capitalization of Eletrobras will take place via capital increase. The company will issue new shares through a primary offering and the federal government will waive its subscription rights. The objective is that the government’s stake (direct and indirect) in the state-owned company be diluted from the current 72.33% of the voting capital to 45% or less. If the primary offering is not enough to reach the desired limit, a secondary offering of the common shares held by the government will be made.

The last major pending issue to be overcome before launching the offering of Eletrobras shares will be the final approval from public spending watchdog TCU, whose members greenlighted, last week, the technical studies for the company’s privatization, but will still be working on the last details of the operation, such as the price of the shares. The expectation in the government is that this process will be concluded by the beginning of April.

From then on, it will be up to the board of the state-run company to define the best moment for the operation. One item on the agenda approved at Tuesday’s meeting was precisely the authorization for the board to establish details of the capitalization as the schedule, structure and prices of the issuance of new shares for the company’s capital increase.

Before the meeting, the Furnas Employees Association (Asef) tried to obtain an injunction in court to suspend the meeting. The request was presented at 7:40 am and before the start of the meeting, around 2 pm, the Court decision that denied the request circulated behind the scenes.

At least four other fronts, headed by, among other actors, Workers’ Party (PT) deputies and the Association of Eletrobras Employees (Aeel), tried to suspend the meeting, through challenges in Court and the Securities and Exchange Commission of Brazil (CVM), but none went ahead.

In all, the shareholders decided, on 12 items contained in the agenda. All of them had to be approved, without exception, for the others to be effective.

The meeting began with the approval of the transfer of control of Eletronuclear and Eletrobras’s stake in Itaipu to Empresa Brasileira de Participações em Energia Nuclear e Binacional (ENBPar).

This new state-owned company was created to keep the federal government’s control over these two assets, which will no longer be controlled by Eletrobras after it is privatized. Under the Constitution, the federal government has monopoly on the operation of nuclear plants in the country. The Itaipu Treaty, signed between Brazil and Paraguay for the construction of the binational plant, also provides for state participation in the hydroelectric plant.

Source: Valor International

https://valorinternational.globo.com

Posts

Court of Accounts greenlights privatization of Eletrobras

Shareholders approve privatization of Eletrobras